Study: Speech Recognition Technology Improves Satisfaction, Workflow and Efficiency
The study, “Provider Adoption of Speech Recognition and its impact on Satisfaction, Documentation Quality, Efficiency, and Cost in an Inpatient EHR,” is available on PubMed Central, the
“This highly in-depth study reinforces the significance of accurate, quality clinical documentation in aiding the provider and supporting patient care,” said Dr.
- 1,070,459 notes completed by 687 distinct providers studied;
- 121 providers completed an electronic pre-implementation survey;
- 108 providers (64 percent physicians, 18 percent nurse practitioners, and 18 percent physician assistants) completed a post-implementation survey with an average of 15 months use of speech recognition; and,
- 53 providers completed both the pre- and post-implementation surveys.
The following qualitative and quantitative results were realized:
- 99-point positive shift in Net Promoter Score® after using speech recognition versus prior input modalities indicating a significant increase in provider satisfaction, while 95 percent of providers reported introducing speech recognition for electronic documentation was a good idea.
- 81 percent of providers reported improved documentation quality and completeness, while 60 percent reported less time spent answering questions and clarifications.
- 84 percent of providers reported significant workflow improvements.
- 57 percent of providers reported decreased time spent documenting the patient encounter, an improvement over prior studies.
- Provider adoption of electronic clinical documentation increased from 20 percent to 77 percent, with a 74 percent speech recognition adoption rate.
- The organization realized an 81 percent reduction in monthly medical transcription costs, resulting in transcription cost savings of
$1.37 millionduring the duration of the study.
“As we shift to a value-based payment model, it is important for providers to get credit reflective of the level of care and quality provided,” said
Health Quest teamed with Nuance to validate and share best practices for implementing speech recognition and expand upon prior research. Through this collaboration, the study also established a new baseline for the impact of speech recognition use on provider adoption, satisfaction, documentation quality, efficiency, and cost that other organizations can leverage and future research can expand upon.
The 31-month study consisted of qualitative and quantitative segments that covered pre-implementation, pilot, implementation and post-implementation phases, resulting in the analysis of more than 1 million provider notes.
- Quantitative method: A new methodology was developed and implemented to measure the adoption of speech recognition by detecting the co-occurrences of speech recognition sessions and EHR note change events for the same provider simultaneously active in the EHR and speech recognition systems. To facilitate the accurate measurement of note volume evolution by various clinical documentation input modalities, data was collected from the EHR, speech recognition solution, and medical transcription solution at
Vassar Brothers Medical Center, which had annual transcription costs of more than $1 million. All quantitative measurements were via retrospective, longitudinal, observational study.
- Qualitative Method: To measure provider satisfaction, documentation quality and efficiency, an electronic survey questionnaire was developed and deployed to assess expectations and experience regarding clinical documentation prior to the implementation of speech recognition and to evaluate the post-implementation documentation experience including speech recognition.
“Teaming with Health Quest on this extensive study brought together two like-minded organizations dedicated to the advancement of healthcare through technology,” said
For more information about Health Quest and
About Health Quest
Health Quest is a family of integrated nonprofit hospitals and healthcare professionals in the
Nuance provides intelligent systems that support a more natural and insightful approach to clinical documentation, freeing clinicians to spend more time caring for patients. Nuance healthcare solutions capture, improve and communicate more than 300 million patient stories each year, helping more than 500,000 clinicians in 10,000 global healthcare organizations to drive meaningful clinical and financial outcomes. Nuance’s award-winning clinical speech recognition, medical transcription, CDI, coding, quality and medical imaging solutions provide a more complete and accurate view of patient care.
Trademark reference: Nuance and the Nuance logo are registered trademarks or trademarks of
Director, Public and Community Affairs
Health Quest Systems
O: 845-554-1736, C: 845-240-4317
Source: Nuance Communications, Inc.